Skip The Stress: Where to Pick Up Your Thanksgiving Pies This Year In The Baltimore Area
Let’s be honest: baking pies from scratch is not for the faint of heart. Measuring cups, rolling pins, and sticky flour-covered counters are not exactly what you want when prepping for Thanksgiving. This year, save yourself the stress and support local businesses by picking up your holiday desserts from some of Baltimore’s finest sweet shops. Trust me—your taste buds (and your family) will thank you!
1. Atwater’s Bakery: Classic Pies Done Right
Locations: Catonsville, Belvedere Square, and The Shops at Kenilworth
If you’re looking for pies with that homemade taste without the hassle, Atwater’s has you covered. They offer a delicious array of Thanksgiving classics, from pumpkin to apple cranberry crisp. With locations across the city, you’ll easily find an option near you. Their pies are made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, making each bite a true taste of Maryland.
Pro Tip: Be sure to order by November 24 to guarantee pickup on the 26th or 27th. Get your order in early—they sell out fast!
2. Bertucco’s Bakery: A Hidden Gem in Hampstead
If you want variety and unique desserts, look no further than Bertucco’s Bakery. From tiramisu to pecan bars and chocolate-covered Oreos, this spot will satisfy every sweet tooth in the family. Their holiday pie selection includes everything from apple to blueberry crumb, with gluten-free options available as well.
Order Deadline: Call 410-374-2500 ASAP to place your order. Gluten-free friends, rejoice—this bakery has options for everyone!
Pro Tip: Don’t leave without trying one of their famous crumb pies. They’re the perfect blend of sweet and crunchy.
3. Dangerously Delicious Pies: For the Adventurous Sweet Tooth
True to its name, Dangerously Delicious Pies will have you coming back for seconds (and maybe thirds). With over 15 varieties of pies, including classics like pumpkin and apple, as well as unique creations like the Baltimore Bomb (loaded with Berger cookies), this shop has something for everyone. Not into sweet pies? They also offer savory options like steak and gruyère.
Order Deadline: Place your orders by November 15. Walk-ins are welcome, but availability can be limited, so plan ahead.
Pro Tip: If you’re a chocolate lover, the toffee crunch pie is a must-try. It’s decadent and perfect for a Thanksgiving treat.
4. Weber’s Cider Mill Farm: A Baltimore Tradition
For many families in Baltimore, picking up a pie from Weber’s Cider Mill Farm is a Thanksgiving tradition. They offer a wide selection of freshly baked pies, including crowd favorites like apple, black cherry, and peach. And if you’re a pumpkin pie fan, theirs is one of the best in the area—creamy, spiced just right, and made with love.
Order Deadline: Make sure to place your order with at least 24 hours’ notice for pickup.
Pro Tip: Grab a pint of their homemade ice cream while you’re there. It’s the perfect pairing with any pie you choose.
5. The Charmery: Ice Cream Pies for a Twist on Tradition
Not a fan of traditional pies? The Charmery has you covered with their limited-edition ice cream pies. They’ve got unique flavors like Speculoos Cheesecake and vegan coconut cream that will wow your guests. Available at their Hampden, Towson, Chevy Chase, and Columbia locations, these pies are a fun and refreshing twist on the usual Thanksgiving desserts.
Order Deadline: Preorder online for pickup anytime between November 8 and 27.
Pro Tip: For something different, try the caramel spiced pumpkin ice cream pie. It’s a delightful fusion of fall flavors.
6. Bethany’s Bakery: Cockeysville’s Hidden Gem for Custom Pies
This quaint bakehouse in Cockeysville knows how to satisfy any sweet tooth craving. Bethany’s Bakery offers a variety of nine-inch fruit pies and custom flavors like chocolate peanut butter and vanilla cream. Beyond pies, their menu includes cakes, cookies, and other pastries. It’s the perfect one-stop shop for all your Thanksgiving dessert needs.
Order Tip: Call 240-341-3225 to place your order. For custom flavors, allow at least a week’s notice to ensure your unique pie is ready in time.
Pro Tip: Their vanilla cream pie is a fan favorite—don’t miss it!
7. Cake By Jason: Timonium’s Sweet Treats by a Celebrity Chef
Chef Jason Hisley’s Timonium shop is known for its creative and delicious offerings. Enjoy traditional favorites like apple and pumpkin pie, or opt for something different with bourbon maple pecan, banana cream, or sweet potato marshmallow pie. If pie isn’t your thing, try their festive Thanksgiving cupcake six-pack for a fun twist on dessert.
Order Tip: Place your order online ASAP for in-store pickup to secure your favorite flavors.
Pro Tip: Their gluten-free pies are a hit—perfect for guests with dietary restrictions!
8. The Corner Pantry: A Mt. Washington Must-Visit
The Corner Pantry in Mt. Washington is whipping up creative pies that will wow your Thanksgiving guests. Choose from their cranberry and sage scones, pumpkin s’mores pie, or toffee apple pie. These unique flavors add a delightful twist to the classic Thanksgiving dessert spread.
Order Tip: Place your order by November 22 to guarantee availability.
Pro Tip: The pumpkin s’mores pie is a crowd-pleaser, blending nostalgia with a gourmet touch.
9. Crust by Mack: Charm City’s Made-From-Scratch Perfection
Amanda Mack’s Crust by Mack offers some of the most beautifully crafted pies in Baltimore. From local apple pie with vanilla bean custard to sweet potato pie topped with a floral crown, every creation is a showstopper. Their mini sweet potato “crustinies” are perfect for a potluck or a small gathering.
Order Tip: Order online ASAP for pickup on November 27.
Pro Tip: The sweet potato pie with floral crown makes for an Instagram-worthy addition to your dessert table.
10. Fenwick Bakery: Parkville’s Classic Pie Haven
Fenwick Bakery has been a staple in Parkville for years, and their Thanksgiving pies are a local favorite. Enjoy flavors like coconut custard, pumpkin, blueberry crumb, and French apple. They also offer other tasty options, such as Boston creme pies and fresh pie dough if you want to bake at home.
Order Tip: Call the bakery ASAP to place your order before they sell out.
Pro Tip: Their blueberry crumb pie is a hit every year—be sure to snag one early!
11. Cafe Dear Leon: Gourmet Pies With a Twist
Nestled in Canton, Cafe Dear Leon is known for its refined, decadent desserts. For Thanksgiving, they offer three show-stopping options: the pecan tart with bourbon caramel mascarpone cream, the pumpkin pie with maple meringue, and the pumpkin Basque cheesecake drizzled with dulce de leche. These aren’t just pies—they’re works of art.
Order Tip: Preorder online as soon as possible for pickup on November 26-27 between 7 a.m. and 3 p.m.
Pro Tip: The pumpkin Basque cheesecake is a must-try for a unique twist on traditional flavors.
12. Charlsie's Bakehouse: Catonsville Crowd Pleaser
If you’re looking for pies that taste like home, head to Charlsie’s Bakehouse in Catonsville. Their Thanksgiving lineup includes a pumpkin buttermilk pie with rosemary caramel, pecan cranberry pie with shortbread crust, and a decadent pumpkin cheesecake with cajeta caramel. Each pie is freshly made with locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that every bite is packed with flavor.
Order Tip: Pre-order online ASAP for in-store pickup.
Pro Tip: The apple double crust pie is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with three pounds of local apples.
13. The Classic Catering People: A Full-Service Dessert Experience
For a variety of holiday treats, look no further than The Classic Catering People in Owings Mills. They offer traditional pies like lattice-topped apple and pumpkin, but they also get creative with desserts like maple bourbon cupcakes and spiced pecan gingerbread Swiss rolls. It’s the perfect option if you’re hosting a big group and want a variety of treats.
Order Tip: Place your pre-orders by November 21 to ensure availability.
Pro Tip: Add their holiday Rice Krispy treats shaped like turkeys for a fun addition to your dessert spread.
14. Maillard Pastries: Decadent Flavors for the Adventurous Sweet Tooth
Maillard Pastries, now with locations in Hampden and Hamilton-Lauraville, is a go-to for those who want something more than the usual pumpkin pie. Their Thanksgiving lineup includes crowd-pleasers like pumpkin cheesecake and pecan tart, but it’s their outside-the-box flavors like the butterscotch pie with decadent custard that really steal the show.
Order Tip: Place your orders by November 22 for pickup on November 27 at your preferred location.
Pro Tip: The butterscotch pie is a game-changer—perfect for those looking to try something different this Thanksgiving.
15. Pie Time: Year-Round Pie Magic in Patterson Park
Pie Time has a well-earned reputation for creating heartwarming pies all year long. For Thanksgiving, they’re rolling out classics like old-fashioned apple pie, maple bourbon pecan pie, and a creamy caramel pumpkin pie. They even cater to vegan diets with options like ginger pumpkin and the creative Cran-Oat Slam, topped with a cranberry compote and a dairy-free crumble.
Order Tip: Order online by November 23 at 3 p.m. for a pickup on November 27.
Pro Tip: The maple bourbon pecan pie is a fan favorite—rich, nutty, and perfect for pairing with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
16. Santoni’s Marketplace & Catering: Classic Pies, Done Right
If you’re all about the classics, Santoni’s Marketplace & Catering in Glyndon is the place to go. Their pie menu keeps it simple but delicious, with options like apple, pumpkin, sweet potato, and pecan. These time-honored recipes have been delighting families for years, making them a reliable choice for your Thanksgiving table.
Order Tip: Be sure to place your orders by November 24 at 4 p.m. to ensure you get your favorite pie.
Pro Tip: The sweet potato pie is a must-try, with a perfectly spiced filling that tastes like home.
17. Sugarbakers: A Cake Lover’s Paradise in Catonsville
Not everyone loves pie, and Sugarbakers has the perfect solution. While they offer traditional pies like pumpkin and Southern pecan, they also turn your favorite holiday flavors into stunning cakes. Options include the pumpkin Smith Island Cake and the pumpkin swirl cheesecake, along with festive turkey-themed cakes and cookies for those looking to mix it up.
Order Tip: Order online or visit in-store to secure your treats before they sell out.
Pro Tip: The pumpkin Smith Island Cake is a showstopper, with multiple layers of rich pumpkin cake and creamy icing.
My Final Thoughts: Skip the Oven, Support Local, and Sweeten Your Holiday
Thanksgiving is about spending time with family—not stressing over a pie that may or may not come out as planned. By choosing to order from one of these fantastic local bakeries, you’re not just getting a delicious dessert, you’re supporting small businesses that are the heartbeat of our community. And if you or someone you know is thinking about buying or selling a home this holiday season, I’d love to be your trusted guide. After all, just like with pies, sometimes it’s better to let an expert handle the heavy lifting.
Enjoy your Thanksgiving and happy pie hunting! ??
Source: Baltimore Magazine
If you have any questions, want to know what the current value of your home is, would like to book an appointment with me or are looking for some free real estate related educational reports; make sure to Check Out My Link tree
Search for your next dream home or find out the value of your current home on my website www.Realvolutionhomes.com
Dan McDevitt
Cummings & Company Realtors
Team Leader, Realvolution Homes Group
f
